1844: During the Democratic convention, former President Martin Van Buren, the front-runner, did not get the needed two-thirds vote on the first ballot. As balloting continued, other candidates (including Sen. James Buchanan of Pennsylvania), whittled away at Van Buren’s lead. On the eighth ballot, James K. Polk, former governor of Tennessee, received a vote. On the ninth ballot, the convention got behind him. “Polk was the first dark-horse candidate to be nominated for president by a major party,” according to William A. DeGregorio and Sandra Lee Stuart in The Complete Book of Presidents, (Barricade Books; 2013).
1852: Four major candidates vied for the Democratic nomination, and none was named Franklin Pierce. With the party unable to agree, Pierce was nominated as a compromise choice on the 35tth ballot. He was chosen as the candidate on the 49th ballot, according to DeGregorio.
1876: During the Republican convention, the front-runner was Sen. James Blaine of Maine. Blaine's problem was that he had not sufficiently confronted charges that he had used his office for personal gain, according to Encyclopedia Britannica online. A stop-Blaine movement gave the momentum to another candidate, Rutherford B. Hayes, who fought for the Union during the Civil War and went on to become Ohio's governor. Hayes became the Republican nominee and was eventually elected president.
1932: There was a movement by the 1928 nominee, Alfred E. Smith of New York, to stop Franklin Roosevelt from winning the Democratic nomination as the party convened in Chicago. Roosevelt's clever campaign managers finagled delegate seating “to isolate pockets of opposition in a sea of Roosevelt supporters and strategically located the convention floor microphones so that the roar of the crowd always favored Roosevelt,” according to the Chicago Historical Society.
1964: The Republicans nominated Sen. Barry Goldwater of Arizona. His primary opponent had been New York Gov. Nelson Rockefeller, whose candidacy was hurt by divorce and remarriage, recounts an article on the PBS website. A stop-Goldwater movement formed around another governor, William Scranton of Pennsylvania. But Goldwater was nominated on the first ballot.
1976: President Gerald R. Ford, the incumbent, faced a challenge from Ronald Reagan, former governor of California. Reagan even announced his pick for vice president, Sen. Richard Schweiker of Pennsylvania. Ford still won the nomination on the first ballot.
1980: President Jimmy Carter was challenged by Sen. Edward M. Kennedy of Massachusetts, who wanted the Democratic convention to change its pledged delegates system, recounts the Miller Center of Public Affairs at the University of Virginia. The senator was unsuccessful. Carter was renominated, but lost the election to Reagan.
Related:
Research: Divided political parties lose
Why was inauguration day changed?
If you would like to comment, give us a shout, or like us on Facebook and tell us what you think.